Home / How We Verify
Editorial Standard

How we verify

Five rules, applied to every file in the library — including the ones that make the library look smaller.

1. The owner's own words, or an official record

Every case rests on the owner's own public telling or an official record — an FDD, a court filing, an FTC or attorney-general action. Nothing enters the library second-hand without being labelled for what it is.

2. Figures print as the source states them

Every figure is printed as its source states it, attributed to that source — the owner, the record, or the publication that reported it. Where a source contradicts itself, the figure in the body of the source governs. Nothing is rounded up, ever.

3. Allegations are labelled allegations

A complaint is not a finding. Allegations are labelled allegations, settlements are labelled settlements, and findings are labelled findings — in the file, in plain words, every time.

4. Every case carries a "last verified" date

Files update in place when the record changes — a lawsuit resolves, a business reopens, a source is corrected — and the date moves with the change.

5. Corrections are made in the open

If a file is wrong, the correction is made on the case page, where a reader can see it. Files are not quietly deleted.

The evidence grades

Evidence: Owner-told — the story comes from the owner's own recorded or written telling.

Evidence: Documented — the story rests on an official record: a court filing, an FDD, a regulator action.

Evidence: Reported account — the story is known through a publication's or program's reported account rather than the owner's verbatim telling; figures are attributed to that reporting.

Evidence: Unverified account — the account is carried in the library labelled as unverified, because its sources could not be opened first-hand. It is published with the label on it, so the gap is part of the record.