A Franchise Disclosure Document runs to hundreds of pages. Four of its items carry the record that matters — plus one page at the front that tells you who you are really dealing with. This checklist walks those five items the way the case files in the Franchise Horror Stories library say they should have been walked.
Every case named here is a real file from the library at franchisehorrorstories.com. Figures are stated the way the record states them — the owner's own account, the court record, or the franchisor's own disclosure — and allegations are labelled as allegations.
The 14 days are yours. By law, the franchisor has to give you the FDD at least 14 calendar days before you sign anything or pay anything. Use the days. They are the cheapest diligence you will ever get.
Item 1
Who the franchisor actually is
Item 1 names the franchisor, its parent companies, its predecessors, and its affiliates — the corporate family tree behind the brand you are buying.
What to look at
How old is the franchisor entity itself — not the brand story, the legal entity that will hold your agreement?
Is there a predecessor that sold a similar business before, under a different name?
Are the people running this brand the same people who ran an earlier one?
Red flags — check each one
A young franchisor company wrapped around an old sales story.
A predecessor entity that did substantially the same thing and is no longer the contracting party.
Officers whose names you will meet again in Item 3, attached to a different brand.
What a bad answer looks like
The brand has "decades of experience," but the company you are signing with was formed recently, and the earlier company — the one with the history — is a separate entity that owes you nothing.
Item 3
The litigation history most buyers skip
Item 3 is where the franchisor must disclose its litigation and bankruptcy history — lawsuits with franchisees, regulator actions, and the bankruptcies of the company and its officers.
What to look at
Read every franchisee lawsuit listed, not just the count.
Look for actions by state regulators and the FTC. Those are findings and orders, not allegations.
Check the officers' bankruptcies, not only the company's. The people recur even when the brand name changes.
Red flags — check each one
A pattern of the same complaint — territory, supply pricing, encroachment — repeated across suits. A pattern is the system describing itself.
Franchisees suing over the same earnings or performance claims you are being pitched right now.
Large settlement payments by franchisees to get out. Item 3 records what exiting costs.
What a bad answer looks like
Pages of suits from the franchisor's own owners, all telling the same story the salesperson just told you couldn't happen — or a settlement line showing an owner paid millions simply to terminate the agreement and walk away.
From the case files — Case 059Documented
Collision Consolidation Co. / Maaco. Maaco's own 2025 FDD, Item 3, records the exit: after suing over alleged false and misleading financial performance representations in the FDD, Collision Consolidation Co. settled in December 2023 and paid Maaco $5.5 million to terminate the franchise agreements, the personal guarantees, and the development agreement. The allegations were never adjudicated — but the price of leaving is printed in the franchisor's own document.
The CheckBefore you sign, read Item 3 for two things — the pattern of the complaints, and what it has cost other owners to leave.
Item 7
The real cost to open, line by line
Item 7 is the franchisor's own table of what it costs to open — franchise fee, build-out, equipment, signage, opening inventory, and the line buyers most often under-read: additional funds for the first months.
What to look at
Add the top of every range, not the bottom. The low number is the brochure number; the high number is the planning number.
Price the "additional funds" line against your own market's rent and wages, not the franchisor's national guess.
Ask what the table leaves out entirely — rent during build-out, your own salary, the months before revenue settles.
Red flags — check each one
A plan that only works using the bottom of every range.
An additional-funds line that covers a few months in a business that takes a year to ramp.
A total that only works if revenue starts in month one.
What a bad answer looks like
The money runs out during construction or in the first slow season — not because the business failed, but because the opening budget was the low end of the franchisor's table plus a guess.
From the case files — Case 016Owner's Account
Valeria Quinones / Pita Pit. Quinones invested $300,000 in a Pita Pit franchise in San Juan, Puerto Rico, that was mid-construction when Hurricane Maria hit. Delays, shortages, and rent forced her to put in $45,000 more of her own money through an owner's equity injection just to finish and open (her account, told to Entrepreneur). That $45,000 is what the "additional funds" line in Item 7 is for.
The CheckRebuild Item 7 at the top of every range, with your market's real rent and wages, and a delay built in. If the deal only survives the low end, it does not survive.
Item 19
Earnings claims: what they show, what they hide
Item 19 is the only place a franchisor may make financial performance claims — and it does not have to. When a claim appears, it is a chosen subset: chosen outlets, chosen years, gross figures before the costs the owner actually carries.
What to look at
Ask what the claim leaves out: how many outlets, which years, gross or net of royalties, fees, rent, and labor.
Ask whether the outlets in the table are the same model you are buying — same size, same format, franchised rather than company-run.
If Item 19 is empty, treat every number said out loud in the sales process as unbacked. The document is the claim, or there is none.
Red flags — check each one
An "average" built from a small, chosen subset of outlets.
Corporate-store numbers used to sell franchised units.
Figures blended from larger, older units applied to a smaller, newer format.
A verbal earnings pitch that is bigger than anything Item 19 will put in writing.
What a bad answer looks like
The claim describes a system you are not buying — different stores, different years, different format — and your unit's economics were never in the document at all.
From the case files — Case 067Allegations Filed
Michele Vice / Hawaii Fluid Art. Vice ran a Hawaii Fluid Art studio in Central Florida for about eighteen months and lost about $400,000 (owner-stated, reported by Franchise Times). She and fifteen other franchisees sued in October 2025, alleging the Item 19 presented fake corporate-store sales — including off-site revenue from a mobile unit the suit alleges never existed. The allegations have not been adjudicated; the loss, in her own telling, is not in dispute.
The CheckTake every number you were told and find it in Item 19 — same outlets, same format, same years. Anything you cannot find there was a sales claim, not a disclosure.
Item 20
How many units closed, transferred, or were taken back
Item 20 is the turnover table: how many outlets opened, closed, were terminated, not renewed, reacquired, or transferred — and the list of former franchisees, with contact details the franchisor must provide.
What to look at
Compute net growth yourself: openings minus closures, terminations, and reacquisitions, year over year.
Read the transfers line closely. A unit sold on is often a unit that failed once already.
Use the former-franchisee list. It is the one reference check the franchisor is required to hand you.
Red flags — check each one
Unit count growing while terminations and reacquisitions grow faster.
Heavy transfers — a resale market inside the system, made of other people's exits.
Former owners who will not take your call, or whose reasons for leaving all sound the same.
What a bad answer looks like
"We opened forty locations last year" — while thirty-five closed, were terminated, or were taken back. A system can grow its unit count while its owners churn. Item 20 is where that shows.
The CheckDo the subtraction yourself, then call former franchisees from the Item 20 list and ask one question — would you sign it again?
Before you sign anything
Run the five items. Then, if the document and the pitch still disagree, believe the document.
Questions while you read? Call +1 251-512-2229, any time. When you want a person to work your specific numbers, the step is a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy: book a consultation.
THE FINE PRINT
Before You Sign — get the checklist
The five FDD items that decide the deal — what to look at, the red flags, and what a bad answer looks like. Free, by email.