George Donaldson's entities, former franchisees of One Hour, Benjamin Franklin and Mister Sparky, sued Clockwork, Inc. and Clockwork IP, LLC in January 2014. They sought a declarat
Source: Benjamin Franklin 2022 FDD, Item 3 — franchisor's litigation disclosure of the VenVest / Clockwork case
George Donaldson's entities, former franchisees of One Hour, Benjamin Franklin and Mister Sparky, sued Clockwork, Inc. and Clockwork IP, LLC in January 2014. They sought a declaration that a slogan his re-branded business used did not infringe the franchisors' trademarks and that non-competition provisions in a separate contract were void under California law, plus unfair-competition and damages claims. The court granted partial summary judgment on the non-compete claims in October 2014. The case settled in May 2015, with Donaldson removing the slogan and dropping the One Hour marks and imagery.
Evidence: Documented
George Donaldson's entities, former franchisees of One Hour, Benjamin Franklin and Mister Sparky, sued Clockwork, Inc. and Clockwork IP, LLC in January 2014. They sought a declaration that a slogan his re-branded business used did not infringe the franchisors' trademarks and that non-competition provisions in a separate contract were void under California law, plus unfair-competition and damages claims. The court granted partial summary judgment on the non-compete claims in October 2014. The case settled in May 2015, with Donaldson removing the slogan and dropping the One Hour marks and imagery.
The court granted the former franchisees partial summary judgment on their non-competition claims in October 2014, before the case settled in May 2015.
The outcome, as the source states it: $50,000 — in a related, separate Florida declaratory case, the franchisor's 2022 FDD states Benjamin Franklin Franchising paid Donaldson $50,000 towards On Time Plumbers' purchase of the franchise; no damages figure is stated for the California case
The Fine Print
This file rests on FDD / disclosure document: Benjamin Franklin 2022 FDD Item 3 and One Hour 2018 FDD Item 3, VenVest Ballard, Inc. v. Clockwork, Inc., Case No. 5:14-cv-00195-MWF-EX (U.S. District Court, Central District of California). Every figure in this file is printed as that source states it, attributed — the standard on the How We Verify page.
Check whether non-compete obligations also sit in contracts separate from the franchise agreement, and what happens to your slogan, marks and customer information on exit — all of those were fought over here.
Filed under: One Hour Heating & Air Conditioning — the documented record · More franchise files · Cases in California
Start with a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy personally. You leave with a written plan that tells you which path fits and what it will cost. The fee is credited toward your launch if you sign.
Want to see how it works first? Visit azgari.com — Azgari Business Launch and Management services. BBB A+ Rated · 5.0 from 11 BBB customer reviews.
The five FDD items that decide the deal — what to look at, the red flags, and what a bad answer looks like. Free, by email.