Home / Cases / CASE 343
CASE 343 · Bought a franchise

Building Werks Holdings, LLC, EA Restoration, LLC and Everett Foytik, LLC — Paul Davis Restoration

Matthew Everett's franchisee entities for three Wisconsin territories sued Paul Davis Restoration in 2011, alleging Wisconsin Fair Dealership Law violations, intentional misreprese

What happened

Matthew Everett's franchisee entities for three Wisconsin territories sued Paul Davis Restoration in 2011, alleging Wisconsin Fair Dealership Law violations, intentional misrepresentation and fraud in the inducement, and Wisconsin Franchise Investment Law violations, and arguing the peer-arbitration system was a sham. The circuit court compelled arbitration of all claims except an unconscionability claim it dismissed, and the Wisconsin Court of Appeals affirmed in 2015, holding the claims must be arbitrated first.

The franchisees argued the peer-arbitration panels of other franchisees would, in all cases, produce an outcome in favor of Paul Davis.

The outcome, as the source states it: No damages figure for the plaintiffs' claims stated in the opinion; a supporting affidavit referred to about $50,000 in past-due franchise payments owed by a former franchisee who sat on an arbitration panel, per the court's opinion

The document

The Fine Print

This file rests on Court record: Wisconsin Court of Appeals, District III, Building Werks Holdings, LLC et al. v. Paul Davis Restoration, Inc., Appeal No. 2014AP1849 (Sept. 29, 2015). Every figure in this file is printed as that source states it, attributed — the standard on the How We Verify page.

What would have caught it

Study the arbitration system before signing, including who sits on the panels, because a challenge to that system may itself have to be arbitrated first.

Case Facts
BrandPaul Davis Restoration
PathBought a franchise
StateWisconsin
Source typeCourt record
Evidence gradeDocumented
Last verifiedNovember 21, 2026
The stories on this site are what the sales process never shows you

Still considering one of these paths?

Start with a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy personally. You leave with a written plan that tells you which path fits and what it will cost. The fee is credited toward your launch if you sign.

Buy a franchise

  • $265K–$573K just to open
  • Royalties ~8% of sales, forever
  • Their brand, their rules

Buy an existing business

  • $350K median price
  • The seller's problems included
  • You, alone, from closing day

Buy a resale

  • Distressed units are cheap for a reason
  • The broker works for the deal
  • The last owner's numbers, not a forecast

Start your own with Azgari

  • Under $265K all-in
  • $0 royalties, ever
  • 100% yours — Azgari runs it with you in year one
Book a Consultation

Want to see how it works first? Visit azgari.com — Azgari Business Launch and Management services. BBB A+ Rated · 5.0 from 11 BBB customer reviews.

Related case files

THE FINE PRINT

Before You Sign — get the checklist

The five FDD items that decide the deal — what to look at, the red flags, and what a bad answer looks like. Free, by email.