Home / Cases / CASE 118
CASE 118 · Franchise resale

Brad Ball & David Ball — May's Custom Tile

Brad Ball and David Ball, through Reperex, Inc., bought May's Custom Tile in Utah in 2008, brokered by Coldwell Banker Commercial agent Duane Bush in claimed dual agency. Per facts

What happened

Brad Ball and David Ball, through Reperex, Inc., bought May's Custom Tile in Utah in 2008, brokered by Coldwell Banker Commercial agent Duane Bush in claimed dual agency. Per facts recited by both Utah appellate courts, Bush showed 2006 profits over $300,000 and withheld the accountant's email stating the business made just over $74,000, and a major client's bankruptcy. The business later failed. Posture: appellate record; broker liability never finally adjudicated.

The broker showed profits over $300,000 while holding an accountant's email saying the business made just over $74,000 in 2006.— Brad Ball & David Ball

The outcome, as the source states it: Profits shown over $300,000 versus just over $74,000 in reality for 2006 — courts' recitation of the buyers' allegations and record, not the buyers' own words; no purchase price or damages figure appears in either opinion

The document

The Fine Print

This file rests on Court record: Utah Court of Appeals, Reperex Inc. v. Child, Van Wagoner & Bradshaw, 2017 UT App 25; Utah Supreme Court, Reperex, Inc. v. Coldwell Banker Commercial, 2018 UT 51. Every figure in this file is printed as that source states it, attributed — the standard on the How We Verify page.

What would have caught it

Get the seller's accountant's underlying figures directly — the broker withheld an email showing just over $74,000 in 2006 profits and a major client's bankruptcy.

Case Facts
BrandMay's Custom Tile
PathFranchise resale
StateUtah
Source typeCourt record
Evidence gradeDocumented
Last verifiedNovember 20, 2026
The stories on this site are what the sales process never shows you

Still considering one of these paths?

Start with a one-hour working session with Azgari Lipshy personally. You leave with a written plan that tells you which path fits and what it will cost. The fee is credited toward your launch if you sign.

Buy a franchise

  • $265K–$573K just to open
  • Royalties ~8% of sales, forever
  • Their brand, their rules

Buy an existing business

  • $350K median price
  • The seller's problems included
  • You, alone, from closing day

Buy a resale

  • Distressed units are cheap for a reason
  • The broker works for the deal
  • The last owner's numbers, not a forecast

Start your own with Azgari

  • Under $265K all-in
  • $0 royalties, ever
  • 100% yours — Azgari runs it with you in year one
Book a Consultation

Want to see how it works first? Visit azgari.com — Azgari Business Launch and Management services. BBB A+ Rated · 5.0 from 11 BBB customer reviews.

Related case files

CASE 296
Franchise Resale · Closets by Design
The exit terms claimed all customer deposits, all records, and possession of the business itself.
No dollar loss figure is stated in the court decision; the exit terms claimed
Todd & Darren Clifford — Closets by Design
CASE 003
Franchise Resale · Dickey's Barbecue Pit · Texas
"some friends of mine approached me with an idea of taking over a foreclosed Dickie's barbecue pit… in Austin"
Out of business within about 13 months (his telling)
Bernard Huang — Dickey's Barbecue Pit
CASE 059
Franchise Resale · Maaco · Michigan
To get out, the franchisee agreed to pay Maaco a total of $5.5 million in exchange for termination of the franchise agreements — Maaco 2025 FDD Item
$5.5 million paid by the franchisee to Maaco under a documented settlement on
Collision Consolidation Co. — Maaco
CASE 087
Franchise Resale · Filta · North Carolina
after closing two months ago, all I want to do now is exit. Buying two franchise territories has been a complete disaster.
Owner stated as approximations: combined purchase price 'about a million
Monte Marcum — Filta